What an open actually is
Open tracking works by hiding a tiny invisible image in your email. When the image loads, the tool logs an open. That's the whole mechanism. Nobody is watching the candidate read your message; something on their end fetched a picture.
That matters because a lot of things fetch pictures now, and most of them aren't the person you emailed.
Why the number is inflated
Apple Mail preloads every image in every email before the person touches it, so everyone on an iPhone or a Mac counts as an open whether they read it or not. Gmail runs images through its own servers and can fetch them ahead of time. Corporate security tools open emails and follow links to check them for threats before they reach the inbox. Bots and spam filters do the same.
Every one of those shows up in your dashboard as a human opening your email. None of them is. So the recruiter who's excited about an 80% open rate is mostly looking at Apple's servers and a few security scanners. The number can only go up from the truth, never down, which makes it useless for comparing one campaign to another.
Why it hurts deliverability
This is the part that costs you real replies. Spam filters know what a tracking pixel looks like. Google and Microsoft spend a lot of money on figuring out what's spam, and an invisible image fetched from a tracking domain is one of the patterns they look for. Marketing email carries them. A note from one person to another doesn't.
Gmail now also puts a warning banner on messages it doesn't trust, with a one-click button to report spam. Recruiters make it worse by sending to personal addresses, which mail providers treat much more strictly than work email. Every complaint that button generates counts against your domain, and you need to stay under 0.3% to keep sending at all.
So the trade is this. You get a number you can't trust, and you pay for it with a higher chance that the next thousand emails never reach an inbox. Most ATS sequencers have tracking on by default. It's one of the reasons email sent from the ATS does worse.
What to track instead
Two numbers. Reply rate and positive reply rate. Everything else is a vanity metric.
Reply rate tells you whether the list and the message are right. Positive reply rate tells you whether the role, the pitch and the timing are right. Between them they cover every decision you'd make about a campaign. If replies are low, fix the list or the copy. If replies are fine but positives are low, fix the pitch or who you're targeting. Opens don't help with either call.
A campaign with an 80% open rate and a 0.4% reply rate is a failing campaign. A campaign with no open rate at all and a healthy reply rate is a working one. Only one of those numbers moves placements.
Every reply from email, LinkedIn and SMS lands in one inbox, with the AI sorting positive from negative, so the two numbers that matter are always on the campaign page.
See how outreach works on TalinBut I need opens to test subject lines
This is the usual objection, and in practice almost nobody is running careful A/B tests on subject lines and preview text. I spent my career in growth marketing before Talin and I wouldn't bother either. Subject lines for recruiter email are a solved problem.
Cut the long subject line with half the role details in it. Spam filters don't like it and the candidate gets a lot of them. Make it one or two words. Hiring for an accountant? The subject line is "Accountant". Then look at your reply rate. If replies went up, the subject line is working; that's the only test you need.
Turn it off
If you're sending candidate or client outreach from a sequencer or an ATS, go into its settings and switch open tracking off. If it can't be switched off, that's worth knowing before you send your next campaign through it. Talin has never had it and won't.
Then send this to the recruiter you know who's excited about their 80% open rate.